Antonia's

Antonia's in Key West has long been considered one of the island's standout Italian restaurants, serving classic Italian cuisine in a setting that manages to feel both romantic and genuinely relaxed. For a town that tends toward casual, Antonia's offers a step up without any stuffiness. The kitchen focuses on time-honored Italian preparations that highlight quality ingredients — pasta, sauces, and regional dishes done with care. It's the kind of place you return to on subsequent Key West visits, because some restaurants earn a permanent spot on the itinerary.